Skip to main content

Serving Pinellas, Pasco, Hillsborough & Manatee

Elise NatoliTampa Bay Real Estate Professional

About Elise Natoli

An educator’s mind for clarity. A coach’s heart for people.

For Elise Natoli, real estate has never been about convincing someone to buy or sell a house—it is about helping people feel informed, supported, and genuinely confident at one of life’s pivotal crossroads.

Before launching her real estate career in April 2024 with Charles Rutenberg Realty, Inc. alongside The Tennant Team, Elise spent more than 10 years as a science educator and earned her certification as a life coach. In the classroom, she learned how to take unfamiliar, complex information and make it clear, structured, and approachable. Through life coaching, she honed the art of deep listening—helping people sort through competing priorities, ask the right questions, and make decisions aligned with their values.

Stepping into real estate was a natural bridge between both callings. Buying or selling a home combines analytical details—market data, property condition, contracts, inspections, and numbers—with deeply personal considerations about daily life and future plans. Clients who appreciate honest communication, thorough preparation, and space to think without sales pressure quickly feel at ease working with Elise.

Because of her decade-plus in education, Elise is also familiar with how families research public school districts, magnet and choice applications, charter options, and state scholarship programs in Florida—always sharing neutral, factual resources from official channels so clients can evaluate what best fits their own needs.

Charles Rutenberg Realty, Inc. — The Standard of Excellence logo
The Tennant Team real estate logo
Elise Natoli smiling in a bright entryway, Tampa Bay Real Estate Professional with Charles Rutenberg Realty, Inc.

At a Glance

  • Originally from New Jersey
  • 10+ years as a science educator
  • Certified life coach
  • Licensed real estate career began April 2024
  • Wife & baseball mom of two boys
  • Loves Gulf beaches, local coffee shops, baking & reading

Service Philosophy

What You Can Expect Working Together

Preparation Before Every Meeting

Whether reviewing neighborhood comps, preparing tour itineraries, or walking through net sheets, Elise does the homework ahead of time so your conversations are productive and clear.

Direct, Honest Answers

If a house has layout limitations, deferred maintenance, or pricing that outpaces comparable sales, Elise tells you plainly. If she needs to verify a municipal or HOA detail, she tracks down the accurate answer rather than guessing.

Steady Communication

You never have to wonder what is happening behind the scenes. Elise keeps you updated on next steps, deadlines, and feedback by phone, text, or email—whichever way you prefer.

Respect for Your Timeline

Some conversations lead to a move next month; others help clarify a plan a year down the road. Either way, you receive the same attentiveness and care.

Outside of Real Estate

At home in Tampa Bay

Originally from New Jersey, Elise lives in the Tampa Bay area with her husband and their two boys. Having made the move from the Northeast herself, she understands firsthand both the excitement and the practical questions that come with putting down roots on Florida’s Gulf Coast.

When she is not researching properties or meeting with clients, you will often find Elise at the baseball field cheering on her sons, enjoying Tampa Bay’s Gulf beaches, or discovering local independent coffee shops and neighborhood restaurants.

At home, she loves cooking, baking desserts, reading, focusing on personal growth, and building meaningful, lasting connections within her community.

No Pressure • Honest Guidance

“Thinking about buying, selling, or simply wondering what your options are? Let’s start with a conversation. No pressure, no obligation, just honest guidance and answers to help you decide what’s right for you.”